When it gets cold, I want a proper pie. Not just a dish of filling with a pastry lid, although I make those all the time and there is absolutely nothing wrong with them. Sometimes, though, you want the whole thing: a crisp base, sturdy pastry sides and a gorgeous golden lid.
This butter chicken pie is exactly that. Spicy chicken thighs in a thick tomato sauce, completely enclosed in homemade hot water crust pastry. It is a lovely centrepiece for a weekend dinner, Thanksgiving, Christmas or New Year’s.
I first experimented with this pastry during my Great British Bake Off days, and making it again reminded me how much I love it. It is soft and wonderful to handle while warm, forgiving if you need to patch a hole, and beautifully crisp once baked.
Table of Contents
- A Quick Curry Inside a Proper Homemade Pie
- Ingredients
- 1. Marinate and Roast the Chicken
- 2. Make the Butter Chicken Filling
- 3. Make the Hot Water Crust Pastry
- 4. Roll Out and Line the Tin
- 5. Fill, Seal and Glaze the Pie
- 6. Bake Until Deeply Golden
- What to Serve with Butter Chicken Pie
A Quick Curry Inside a Proper Homemade Pie
The filling is based on the 30-minute butter chicken from my cookbook, Chetna’s 30 Minute Indian. I am keeping the curry quick because the focus here is getting a delicious pie on the table, not making the most extensive version of butter chicken.
The trick is to roast the marinated chicken while the tomato sauce cooks on the hob. Both take around 15 minutes, so you are doing two jobs at once.
The curry takes about 30 minutes, not the complete pie. You will also need time to make and shape the pastry, bake the pie for about an hour, and let it rest before removing it from the tin.
- Serves: 4, with some curry potentially left over depending on how generously you fill the pie.
- Tin: An 8-inch loose-bottomed cake tin. A springform tin is also suitable.
- Pie baking time: About 1 hour.
- Resting time: About 30 minutes before removing from the tin.
Ingredients
For the Chicken and Marinade
- 8 to 10 boneless, skinless chicken thighs, cut into roughly 1-inch pieces
- 200 g Greek yogurt or natural yogurt
- 2 to 3 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- A generous piece of fresh ginger, finely chopped
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon chilli powder
- 1 tablespoon tandoori masala, optional
- 2 tablespoons mustard oil, or your usual cooking oil
For the Tomato Sauce
- Oil, for cooking
- 2 bay leaves
- 3 to 5 green cardamom pods
- 1 cinnamon stick
- A few cloves
- 2 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- 400 ml passata
- About 50 ml water, to rinse out the passata jar
- 1 teaspoon garam masala
- 1 teaspoon chilli powder
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon clear honey
- 1 tablespoon kasuri methi, or dried fenugreek leaves
My quick butter chicken recipe normally uses 200 ml passata, but here I use a whole 400 ml jar. The important thing for the pie is to reduce the finished curry until it is thick rather than leave it loose and saucy.
For the Hot Water Crust Pastry
- 450 g plain flour, also called all-purpose flour
- 100 g strong white bread flour
- 1 teaspoon chilli powder, optional
- 75 g cold unsalted butter, cut into small cubes
- 200 ml water
- 100 g vegetarian shortening
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 1 egg, beaten, for glazing and sealing
I use vegetarian shortening rather than animal lard. You will usually find it near the lard in the supermarket.
1. Marinate and Roast the Chicken
Heat the oven to 220°C conventional or 200°C fan.
Put the yogurt in a large bowl and add the finely chopped ginger and garlic, salt, chilli powder, tandoori masala and mustard oil. Mix everything together, then add the chicken and turn it through the marinade until every piece is coated.
If you have tandoori masala, lovely, add it. If you do not, you can still make this. The same goes for the oil: mustard oil is my usual choice for this marinade, but your regular cooking oil will work too.
There is no compulsory marinating time for this quick version. Cook it straight away if, like me, you have not planned ahead. If you do have time, cover and refrigerate it for an hour or two, or overnight.
Spread the chicken over a roasting tray and roast for about 10 to 15 minutes, until cooked through. Start the sauce while it is in the oven.
2. Make the Butter Chicken Filling
Heat some oil in a pan. Add the bay leaves, cardamom pods, cinnamon stick and cloves. Let them warm and sizzle so they release their flavour into the oil, then stir in the chopped garlic.
Add the passata. Rinse the jar with about 50 ml water and pour that into the pan too. Cover and cook gently for around 15 minutes, alongside the chicken in the oven.
Stir in the garam masala, chilli powder, salt and honey. Add the kasuri methi, rubbing the leaves between your palms as you sprinkle them into the sauce, then add the cooked chicken.
Now comes the important difference between a curry for dinner and a curry for a pie. If I were serving this with naan, I would add a little more water. For the pie, do not add any extra water. Increase the heat and cook, stirring, for about 2 minutes to drive off more moisture. You want plenty of sauce coating the chicken, but no excess liquid.
Turn off the heat and let the filling cool slightly while you prepare the pastry ingredients.
Honestly, this is the point where it becomes very tempting to stop, make some lachha paratha or naan, and eat the curry just as it is. But the pastry is worth carrying on for.
3. Make the Hot Water Crust Pastry
Set the oven to 200°C conventional or 180°C fan for baking the pie. Have your tin, rolling pin and a clear work surface ready before mixing the pastry, because you will shape it while it is warm.
Rub the Butter into the Flour
Combine the plain flour, strong white bread flour and optional chilli powder in a large bowl. Add the small cubes of cold butter.
Using your fingertips, rub the butter into the flour until the mixture looks like breadcrumbs. Keep some flour around the butter as you rub, rather than squeezing the butter on its own.
I love doing this by hand. It is one of the really joyous parts of making pastry. Some people freeze and grate their butter, but small chilled cubes are what I use here.
Add the Hot Liquid
Put the water, vegetarian shortening and salt in a small saucepan. Heat until the shortening has melted and the liquid comes to the boil. There is no need to keep boiling it once you have reached that point.
Pour the hot mixture into the flour and start mixing with a wooden spoon. It is very hot, so do not put your hands straight in.
Once it is cool enough to handle safely, bring it together by hand into a soft dough. You are not trying to knead it like bread; just gather it into a cohesive pastry that you can roll.
4. Roll Out and Line the Tin
Pinch off a smaller portion of dough and set it aside for the lid. Roll the larger portion into a round wide enough to cover the base and sides of your 8-inch tin.
This pastry has enough fat that I do not need extra flour on the work surface. Keep lifting and moving it as you roll. If you are less confident about transferring it, roll it on baking parchment so you can use that to help lift it.
- Work while it is warm: Bring the dough together, roll it and line the tin promptly.
- Do not roll it paper-thin: This is a sturdy pastry, not a delicate shortcrust.
- Patch any holes: A small tear is not a disaster. Press a little pastry over it.
Lift the pastry over the rolling pin and lower it into the tin. Gently ease it into the base and corners, pressing it against the sides. Trim away the large overhanging pieces, leaving enough pastry at the top to join to the lid.
5. Fill, Seal and Glaze the Pie
Pick the whole spices out of the curry before filling the pie. They have already done their job, and this is a good opportunity to remove the bay leaves, cinnamon, cardamom pods and cloves.
Spoon the chicken into the pastry case, making sure it reaches the edges and corners. You do not have to use every last spoonful. I leave some curry for another meal with roti or rice because the pie already holds enough for four.
Roll the reserved pastry into a lid. Brush the pastry edge where the lid will join with beaten egg, then lay the lid directly over the filling. If the filling sits below the rim of the tin, the lid can sit lower too.
Trim off excess pastry so you do not end up with an unnecessarily thick lip. Pinch the lid and sides together, then crimp all the way around in whatever way you like. I simply pinch the pastry between my fingers.
Brush the top with beaten egg and cut a small slit in the centre to let steam escape. Keep the pastry trimmings for another use rather than throwing them away.
6. Bake Until Deeply Golden
- Bake at 200°C conventional or 180°C fan for 10 minutes.
- Reduce the temperature to 180°C conventional or 160°C fan.
- Bake for another 40 to 50 minutes, checking the colour after 40 minutes at the lower temperature.
Mine needs the full 50 minutes at the lower temperature, making 1 hour of baking altogether. The chicken filling is already cooked; this stage is about heating it through and properly baking the pastry.
Look for a gorgeous, deeply golden crust, not just a lightly coloured lid.
Leave the pie in its tin for about 30 minutes before removing it. I initially think a short rest will do, but this is a very hot pie, so give it time and handle the tin carefully.
What to Serve with Butter Chicken Pie
A crunchy green salad is lovely alongside this rich, spicy pie. That is my choice when I want something fresh on the plate.
Roast potatoes would also be delicious, especially as the winter weather sets in. And my slightly controversial choice? Rice. I know there is already pastry, but a little rice with that chicken filling would be absolutely lovely.
There is something very familiar about the combination, really. Paratha brings together flour and butter, and so does this pastry. This is simply another way to wrap delicious butter chicken in something golden and comforting.
The chicken is spicy and full of flavour, the pastry is crisp, and the whole pie feels like a proper occasion. Making it has reminded me that hot water crust pastry deserves to come out of my recipe folder much more often.


